• MyPE
  • My Nelson Mandela Bay
  • Port Elizabeth Business Directory

Your Ad HERE

Your Ad HERE

My Port Elizabeth

  • Team
    • MyPE
    • Google News
    • NMBT
    • Bing News
    • Uitenhage.org.za
    • NMBBC
    • The Herald
  • Contact
  • Accommodation
  • #PE on Instagram
  • Submit News
  • Weather
  • Directory
  • 24 April 2018
You are here: Home / Nelson Mandela Bay / Public interest appeal goes before SCA

Public interest appeal goes before SCA

16 November 2012 By Google

It was brought by Eastern Cape local government MEC, Mlibo Qoboshiyane.

The matter related to a case between the MEC and Avusa Publishing’s Herald newspaper, in Port Elizabeth. It was brought before the Port Elizabeth High Court in March 2011.

The Herald applied on November 24, 2010, for access to the Kabuso Report, a section 106 report, in terms of the Municipal Systems Act.

The report, which the MEC received in February 2010, followed an investigation into possible maladministration at the Nelson Mandela Bay metro municipality.

In October 2011, the high court ordered that the report be handed to the newspaper within five days, which was done by the MEC.

In papers in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA), the MEC agreed with the high court findings about handing the report to the newspaper, but questioned the court’s conclusion that section 46 of the Promotion of Access to Justice Act required disclosure of the report.

Section 46 provides a limited public interest override of the mandatory protection of information.

On Wednesday, the judges of a full SCA Bench questioned the appeal, because the right to appeal stopped when the MEC complied with the court order.

There was also no indication on the papers that the MEC had reserved the right to appeal when he handed over the report.

“There is no issue on the papers that there was a right reserved,” said Appeal Court Judge Kenneth Mthiyane.

Richard Buchanan, for the MEC, said what was required was a decision whether information in a section 106 investigation could be made available before the end of the investigative process and before an MEC’s final decision.

“Is it proper to hold back a report if the process [investigation] was not finished?” he asked.

He argued that this was a different situation from whether a similar report was deliberately delayed, which would set in motion an argument of public interest.

Buchanan submitted that section 106 investigations would be undermined if the investigative process were played out on the front pages of the press.

Section 106 investigations would always end in a decision by an MEC, which would be in the public domain.

Buchanan submitted that a court decision on “premature disclosures” would set a guide for the press, public and government officials on how to handle similar situations, which were sure to surface in the future.

Jason Brickhill, for Avusa, submitted that the appeal should be dismissed with costs.

He said that in the case before court, the section 106 investigation was completed by the time access was sought by the newspaper.

“We accept there was ongoing exchange between the MEC and the municipality, but the report was finished.”

Brickhill argued that any public interest argument was fact based within its own context, and rested on a discretionary aspect.

Referring to the Kabuso report, Brickhill said a delay of 18 months after the report was finished and no finality in the section 106 processes would bring a significant aspect of public interest into play in any similar matters.

The SCA asked the MEC for additional information.

This included whether the report was handed over during a public ceremony and whether there was a reservation lodged for a possible appeal.

Mthiyane reserved judgment on the matter.

Source: Sapa via I-Net Bridge

Article source: http://www.bizcommunity.com/Article/196/546/85474.html

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google
  • More
  • Print
  • Pocket
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit

Previous: Port Elizabeth gets ready for Afcon 2013
Next: Port Elizabeth office for Dachser


Filed Under: Nelson Mandela Bay Tagged With: google, herald, mype, news, port elizabeth

Find a PE Business







Random PE News

2030 Nuclear energy plan likely to fail

Bay hosts chess elite

PE in the news: Rabada: Important we still speak a positive language

Grahamstown in the news: EduPlanet still operating

There’s ‘gold’ in them thar potatoes

GMSA Supports Vital Skills Base For the Automotive Industry

Uitenhage in the news: South Africa: Man Found Murdered in Street – Kwanobuhle

Flea market lures in fishermen

VW Rally 2014 finish moves to Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium

SS Mendi exhibition

Heroic Ingram not enough for Warriors

Bhisho news: Mistress bites back in advert

DA has already achieved much in Port Elizabeth, says Maimane …

World Record Challenge: Upload 1000 YouTube Adverts in 10 Days

Port Elizabeth in the News on 11 April 2015

Winston-Salem, North Carolina

Star line-up for free Cape jazz concert

Autism school in Port Elizabeth celebrates 21 years

ANC’s vote-support loss sees opposing ratings views

Machine Triumphs

More PE Goodness

  • Accommodation
  • Submit News
  • Tour Port Elizabeth




RSS Cape Town News

  • Tactical battles ensue as Volvo Ocean Race fleet navigates St Helena High
  • Cape Town Image: Towards False Bay
  • Earth Day Call To End Plastic Pollution: Whitehouse
  • Cape Town Image: Fraser Island 0118
  • Set-up begins for Volvo Ocean Race as 100000+ expected to flock to Newport

RSS Durban News

  • KZN man attacked for ‘outstanding sex worker bill’
  • Ballito resident crowdfunds for Rabies Awareness after attack.
  • KZN top cop appoints ‘high-level’ team to investigate Moses Mabhida pitch invasion
  • Durban Image: New stunt with ‘human trees’
  • KZN ready for elective conferences – ANC

RSS News from Johannesburg

  • 2 schools specialising in nuclear technology launched in Atteridgeville
  • Eskom’s Abraham Masango cleared of all charges
  • Urban African Agency | Joburg
  • Higher education gets R7bn financial aid boost
  • The New Maverick Ride At Gold Reef City Amusement Park

Copyright © MyPE · Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South Africa | Privacy Policy